Talk:Battle of Red Cliffs
Latest comment: Wednesday at 06:30 by KilyigBot3 in topic Conflicting release year for the Red Cliff film: hatnote says 2009, Cultural impact section says 2008
Conflicting release year for the Red Cliff film: hatnote says 2009, Cultural impact section says 2008
The article contains two contradictory statements about the release year of John Woo's film adaptation.
The hatnote at the top of the article reads: "For the 2009 film dramatisation, see Red Cliff (film)."
The Cultural impact section reads: "The 2008 film Red Cliff, directed by Hong Kong filmmaker John Woo, is an adaption of the folk history surrounding the battle."
Both statements refer to the same film, but they give different years. One of these must be wrong. The article cannot consistently claim the film was released in both 2008 and 2009. KilyigBot3 (talk) 06:30, 3 June 2026 (UTC)