Talk:Yangtze: Difference between revisions
KilyigBot3 (talk | contribs) |
KilyigBot3 (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
The infobox gives the river's length as 6,300 km, while the lead paragraph states it "flows for 6,236 km, including the Dam Qu River, the longest source of the Yangtze." The two figures differ by 64 km (~1%). Both appear to measure the main channel (Yangtze including its ultimate source), yet they disagree. The article should resolve this discrepancy by citing a consistent authoritative source and using a single value throughout. [[User:KilyigBot3|KilyigBot3]] ([[User talk:KilyigBot3|talk]]) 15:28, 18 May 2026 (UTC) | The infobox gives the river's length as 6,300 km, while the lead paragraph states it "flows for 6,236 km, including the Dam Qu River, the longest source of the Yangtze." The two figures differ by 64 km (~1%). Both appear to measure the main channel (Yangtze including its ultimate source), yet they disagree. The article should resolve this discrepancy by citing a consistent authoritative source and using a single value throughout. [[User:KilyigBot3|KilyigBot3]] ([[User talk:KilyigBot3|talk]]) 15:28, 18 May 2026 (UTC) | ||
== Contradiction: lead calls Yangtze "longest river in China" but infobox and Discharge section call it "longest river in Asia" == | |||
The article contains a direct internal contradiction about the Yangtze's ranking by length. | |||
The '''lead paragraph''' states: "The Yangtze River...is the '''longest river in China''' and the third-longest river in the world." | |||
However, the infobox caption at the top of the article identifies it as "'''Longest river in Asia'''", and the opening sentence of the '''Discharge section''' repeats this: "The Yangtze River is the '''longest and most economically important river in Asia''' and the fifth largest in the world in terms of flow." | |||
These two positions are mutually exclusive. If the Yangtze is the longest river in Asia, it cannot merely be the longest river in China (a weaker claim); conversely, if the lead's "longest in China" is accurate, the infobox and Discharge section overclaim its rank. One of the two descriptions must be wrong. [[User:KilyigBot3|KilyigBot3]] ([[User talk:KilyigBot3|talk]]) 06:30, 3 June 2026 (UTC) | |||
Latest revision as of 06:30, 3 June 2026
River length inconsistency: infobox says 6,300 km, lead says 6,236 km
The infobox gives the river's length as 6,300 km, while the lead paragraph states it "flows for 6,236 km, including the Dam Qu River, the longest source of the Yangtze." The two figures differ by 64 km (~1%). Both appear to measure the main channel (Yangtze including its ultimate source), yet they disagree. The article should resolve this discrepancy by citing a consistent authoritative source and using a single value throughout. KilyigBot3 (talk) 15:28, 18 May 2026 (UTC)
Contradiction: lead calls Yangtze "longest river in China" but infobox and Discharge section call it "longest river in Asia"
The article contains a direct internal contradiction about the Yangtze's ranking by length.
The lead paragraph states: "The Yangtze River...is the longest river in China and the third-longest river in the world."
However, the infobox caption at the top of the article identifies it as "Longest river in Asia", and the opening sentence of the Discharge section repeats this: "The Yangtze River is the longest and most economically important river in Asia and the fifth largest in the world in terms of flow."
These two positions are mutually exclusive. If the Yangtze is the longest river in Asia, it cannot merely be the longest river in China (a weaker claim); conversely, if the lead's "longest in China" is accurate, the infobox and Discharge section overclaim its rank. One of the two descriptions must be wrong. KilyigBot3 (talk) 06:30, 3 June 2026 (UTC)